Contractor Disputes
Resolving Installation & Construction Disputes with Evidence
When a flooring installation goes wrong, the dispute between homeowner, contractor, and builder can escalate quickly. Our independent inspections determine whether failures are caused by installation workmanship, construction defects, product issues, or environmental factors — providing the evidence all parties need to reach resolution.
Flooring installation disputes are among the most contentious issues in residential and commercial construction. The homeowner blames the installer. The installer blames the product. The builder blames the subfloor. The manufacturer blames the installation. Without an independent, certified inspection, these disputes can drag on for months or years without resolution.
My Floor Inspection Inc. provides the independent technical analysis that breaks the deadlock. Our certified inspectors evaluate the installation against industry standards (NWFA, FCITS, NALFA, ASTM), assess subfloor conditions, test for moisture, and determine the actual cause of the failure. Because we do not sell, install, or repair flooring, our findings are trusted by homeowners, contractors, builders, manufacturers, and attorneys alike.
What We Do
Contractor Disputes Services
Installation Workmanship Disputes
We evaluate whether flooring was installed according to manufacturer specifications and industry standards. Common installation defects include insufficient acclimation, improper subfloor preparation, inadequate expansion gaps, incorrect adhesive application, and failure to follow manufacturer instructions.
Builder Disputes
When a new construction or renovation has flooring failures, we determine whether the cause is a builder issue (subfloor preparation, moisture control, HVAC operation), an installation issue, or a product issue. Our reports clearly assign responsibility based on technical evidence.
Contractor Quality Evaluations
Homeowners and property managers rely on our independent quality evaluations to assess whether a contractor's flooring installation meets industry standards. We document all defects and provide repair recommendations where appropriate.
Construction Defect Investigations
Comprehensive investigations of construction-related flooring failures including subfloor deflection, concrete slab moisture vapor emission, inadequate vapor barriers, HVAC-induced humidity fluctuations, and water intrusion during construction.
Independent Project Assessments
For large or multi-unit projects, we provide independent project assessments that evaluate installation quality across the entire scope. These assessments are valuable for builders, developers, HOAs, and commercial property owners.
Repair Recommendations
When failures are identified, we provide clear, technically justified repair recommendations. This ensures that repairs address the root cause — not just the visible symptoms — and prevents recurring problems.
Why This Matters
Installation disputes often come down to one party's word against another's. Our certified inspections replace opinion with evidence. We test against published industry standards (NWFA Installation Guidelines, ASTM F2170, ASTM F1869, ANSI standards) and manufacturer specifications. When we identify an installation defect, we document it with measurements and photos. When the installation is correct, we say so — and investigate other causes. Objectivity is what makes our reports effective in resolving disputes.
Our Process
How It Works
Dispute Intake
We review the dispute details, contract documents, installation records, product information, and any prior inspections or communications between the parties.
Standards-Based Inspection
We conduct a comprehensive on-site inspection testing against manufacturer specifications and published industry standards including NWFA, ASTM, and ANSI guidelines.
Root Cause Determination
We identify the actual cause of the flooring failure — whether it's installation workmanship, construction defect, product issue, moisture, or environmental factors.
Resolution Report
We deliver a detailed report with all findings, evidence, and repair recommendations — designed to help all parties reach resolution without unnecessary litigation.
Questions & Answers
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you determine if my flooring was installed incorrectly?
Yes. We evaluate installations against manufacturer specifications and published industry standards including NWFA Installation Guidelines, ASTM standards, and ANSI specifications. Common installation defects we identify include insufficient acclimation, improper subfloor preparation, inadequate expansion gaps, incorrect adhesive trowel size, and failure to follow manufacturer instructions.
Do you take sides in contractor disputes?
No. We are completely independent and do not sell, install, or repair flooring. Our findings are based solely on technical evidence and industry standards. We have no financial interest in the outcome of the dispute. We document what we find — whether it supports the homeowner, the contractor, or neither party.
What is a construction defect investigation?
A construction defect investigation identifies whether a flooring failure is caused by a construction issue rather than a product or installation issue. Common construction defects include subfloor deflection, concrete slab moisture vapor emission, inadequate vapor barriers, missing or insufficient underlayment, HVAC-induced humidity fluctuations, and water intrusion during or after construction.
Can your report be used in court?
Yes. Our reports are prepared to forensic standards and are regularly used in mediation, arbitration, and litigation. We also provide expert witness testimony when needed. Visit our Expert Witness page for more information.
How do you assign responsibility in a dispute?
We do not assign legal responsibility. We provide technical findings based on evidence and industry standards. We document what caused the failure, whether it meets or violates published standards, and what corrective action is recommended. Attorneys and parties use our findings to negotiate or litigate responsibility.
Common Flooring Issues
Ready to Resolve Your Flooring Dispute?
Get an independent, certified inspection with evidence-based findings.
Start Inspection Request